Warning: There will be spoilers for earlier books in the series in the review below. Read at your own risk!
When we last saw our heroine, Cammie Morgan (aka The Chameleon) had just narrowly escaped the clutches of the nefarious Circle of Cavan during an attack that had left suspected double agent (but in reality triple agent) Joe Solomon in a coma. Knowing that she was endangering everyone she loved, Cammie ran away determined to find out why the Circle wanted her and what they had done to her father five years earlier. Out of Sight, Out of Mind (Disney Hyperion Books 2012) picks up 4 months later when Cammie wakes up in an isolated Austrian convent with her oddly emaciated body covered in bruises and various other injuries, her hair cut short and dyed, and oh yeah…NO MEMORY. Oh God, it’s just like the third season of Alias! Which granted, was not the best season of that show, but I blame the convoluted Rimbaldi mythology and Melissa George’s craptastic acting “skills” rather than the amnesia plot.
Oh sorry, I just had to spend an hour watching Alias clips on You Tube, but I’m back now. ANYWAY, once she returns to The Gallagher Academy for Exceptional Young Women (you know, the spy school for girls), nothing is the same. For one, her friends, who are pissed that she left without them, don’t seem that happy to see her. Their reactions range from falsely cheerful to downright hostile. Also, it seems like her sorta-boyfriend, Zach, has gotten quite close to her best friend over the summer. The CIA and school trustees aren’t entirely sure that Cammie should be trusted, and for good reason. She’s behaving erratically, losing time, and seems to have picked up a few new … skill sets during her time away. With the help of new faculty member, Dr. Steve, Cammie and her friends try to piece together what happened over summer vacation.
This story is the darkest installment to the Gallagher Girls series yet and I loved every second of it. So I decided, in true Cammie Morgan style, to make a PRO/CON list detailing my feelings about this book.
PROS AND CONS OF OUT OF SIGHT, OUT OF TIME
(A list by Captain Awesome)
PRO: Amneeeeesia! I wasn’t kidding in our 2012 preview post that my love of amnesia stories stems from a lifetime of watching daytime television. And yes, it can be kind of a cheesy cliche on the soaps, but there’s something fundamentally terrifying about losing your memory. We are who we are because of a culmination of our life experiences and if you can’t remember those experiences, then I’d imagine that would be pretty disconcerting. In Cammie’s case, she’s clearly undergone some kind of physical trauma, most likely torture, and her Mom is urging her NOT to try and remember the pain. It makes for some pretty great drama.
CON: Because of the amnesia, the reader only gets the same bits and pieces that Cammie herself remembers. While this brings a lovely tension to the narrative, it also means that we never find out everything that happened over the summer. A part of me thinks that this is a really interesting stylistic choice, but the rest of me wants to know EVERYTHING THAT HAPPENED RIGHT NOW DAMNIT!
PRO: Ahh, the unreliable narrator: a classic literary trope. I love it because it always keeps the reader guessing. Is Cammie just traumatized or has she gone crazy? Or is she even working for the enemy? I don’t know and it’s fantastic.
CON: Because Ally Carter has done such a good job of making us care about Cammie over the four previous books, it’s difficult to watch her go through such hell in this one. I just want to give her a hug. And as some of you know, I am not normally a hugger.
PRO: One of Ally Carter’s strengths is writing relatable teenage girls in unrelatable circumstances. Despite the whole spy thing, Cammie and her friends feel very much like real teenage girls.
CON: Real teenage girls can be really annoying. Hey Bex, I understand that you’re mad at Cammie for leaving without you, but she’s been tortured. Cut her some slack! And Cammie, yelling at your mother because she didn’t find you when you specifically did everything you could to keep that from happening, makes me want to smack you.
PRO: Zach is now a Gallagher Girl! As another target of the the Circle Cavan, it makes sense that he would only be safe at the Gallagher Academy, but the idea of Zach in his little uniform, taking classes and eating breakfast with all the other girls really amuses me. Plus since all of his secrets are now out, he’s dropped that cryptic yet smirky facade and now has a haunted protector thing going for him that I’m sure will make all the teenaged girls swoon.
CON: I am not a teenager, so even though I like the Zach character quite a lot, I did not swoon. The romance angle aspect of the story is fine, but not the most interesting part of the series for me.
PRO: Ally Carter manages to tie together the events of the first book, I’d Tell You I Love You, But Then I’d Have to Kill You, to the main series arc. Aside from setting up Gallagher Academy and the main characters, the first book has always seemed different in tone to me and almost unconnected to the books that followed, so it’s nice to see how it fits with the series as a whole.
CON: It’s a really small connection and I kind of wish that she’d gone all out with it instead. Like maybe have the whole town of Roseville be spies for the Circle or something. Oh God, it’s possible that I really have been watching too much Alias, isn’t it?
PRO: I seriously think that this is one of the best designed series in YA. I mean between the school uniform plaid and the ransom note style lettering, you know exactly what the basic premise of the series is. Genius. And this one is no exception. The darker cover definitely reflects the darker tone of the story and will look so pretty on my bookshelf next to the others in the series. And that’s really what’s most important.
CON: There’s one of those headless girls on the cover, which I know bothers some people, but I’m ok with it.
PRO: Ally Carter wraps up the story for this book quite nicely, but also clearly sets up the premise for the 6th and final book of the series. And it’s going to be good, guys!
CON: We’ll probably have to wait like a year for the next book. Boo.
PRO: “‘You know,’ I whispered, ‘some girls might think it’s creepy having a boy watch them sleep.'” (pg. 282) Bless you, Cammie Morgan.
And now, just because, a clip from Alias:
And the book trailer: